Book Bans in U.S. Schools: A Growing Concern
A recent report by PEN America, titled “Banned in the USA,” has shed light on the alarming trend of book bans in U.S. schools. The report, which tracks instances of book removals for the 2024-2025 school year, found that Stephen King is the author most likely to be censored, with 206 instances of his books being banned or restricted. This phenomenon is not limited to King’s works, as the report documented over 6,800 instances of book removals, with some states being more prone to censorship than others.
A Divided Country
The report highlights a stark divide between states that actively restrict books and those that attempt to limit or eliminate bans. Florida, Texas, and Tennessee are among the states with the highest number of book bans, with over 80% of the total instances originating from these three states. In contrast, states like Illinois, Maryland, and New Jersey have laws that limit the authority of school and public libraries to pull books, resulting in little to no instances of removals. According to Kasey Meehan, director of PEN’s Freedom to Read program, “It is increasingly a story of two countries,” with differences in book banning policies evident not only between states but also within them.
Reasons Behind Book Bans
The reasons cited for pulling books often include LGBTQ+ themes, depictions of race, and passages with violence and sexual violence. However, the report notes that thousands of books were removed from shelves in anticipation of community, political, or legal pressure, rather than in response to a direct threat. This trend, which PEN describes as “obeying in advance,” is rooted in fear or a desire to avoid controversy. The report also found that Anthony Burgess’ “A Clockwork Orange” was the most banned work, with 23 removals, followed by books from authors like Patricia McCormick, Judy Blume, and Jennifer Niven.
Censorship Efforts
The PEN report comes amid ongoing censorship efforts from states, conservative activists, and even the federal government. The Department of Education has ended an initiative to investigate the legality of bans and has downplayed the issue as a “hoax.” Furthermore, the Department of Defense has removed hundreds of books from K-12 school libraries for military families as part of a broader campaign against diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives. In Florida, where over 2,000 books were banned or restricted, a handful of counties were responsible for many of the King removals, with dozens of his books pulled as part of a review for compliance with state laws.
Methodology and Limitations
PEN’s methodology differs from that of the American Library Association, which also issues annual reports on book bans and challenges. While the library association only counts permanent removals or restrictions, PEN’s report includes any books removed or restricted for any length of time, resulting in a higher total number of instances. Both organizations acknowledge that their numbers are far from comprehensive, as they rely largely on media reports and information received directly. The report does not include data from states like Ohio, Oklahoma, and Arkansas, due to inadequate documentation.
Conclusion
The PEN America report highlights the growing concern of book bans in U.S. schools, with Stephen King being the most banned author. The report’s findings underscore the need for a nuanced understanding of the complex issues surrounding book censorship and the importance of protecting intellectual freedom. For more information, visit Here
Image Source: www.latimes.com
